UserTesting Alternative Using Your Own Users
UserTesting gives you recordings of people from its panel doing your task. UserTold gives you recordings of your own users doing your task inside your product. This page compares the two and says when each one fits. Facts about UserTesting are taken from its own site in November 2026.
Side by side
| UserTesting | UserTold | |
|---|---|---|
| Who takes the test | People from a panel of more than 7 million participants, or your customers through an invitation link | Users of your product, invited by a widget on your site or by a link |
| Where the test runs | On the UserTesting platform | On your own site, in the product the user already has open |
| What is recorded | Screen and voice; camera in some tests | Screen, clicks and voice |
| Questions after the task | Written tasks and questions; AI follow-up questions are in limited early access | A voice conversation about the pauses and wrong turns just captured |
| How problems are found | AI summaries, friction detection, transcripts, highlight reels | Each moment where the user had trouble is marked with their words, the page and the time |
| Access for coding agents | An MCP server in early access for selected teams | An MCP server and a CLI, open to every account |
| Price | Not published; annual plans on request | $0.25 per recorded minute, no subscription |
When a tester panel is the right tool
A panel gives you people on demand. Use it when:
- you have no users yet;
- you need a specific audience you cannot reach, such as nurses or people who have never seen your brand;
- you are testing a prototype or a competitor's site;
- you need twenty sessions by tomorrow.
UserTold does not recruit anyone. If you cannot reach users yourself, a panel is the tool you need.
What a panel cannot give you
A panel tester is not your user. They have no account history, no real data in the product and no reason of their own to finish the task.
Problems that depend on real context stay hidden: a setting the user changed last month, a plan limit they have reached, the words their own team uses for a thing.
What testing with your own users looks like
You write one task and choose the page where it starts. The UserTold widget offers the test on the pages you choose. A user who accepts sees the task and does it in their own account while saying what they are thinking. Afterwards the voice model asks about what just happened.
You get the full recording, and each moment where the user had trouble is marked with their words, the page and the time. A coding agent reads those moments over MCP or the CLI and can start on a fix with the user's own words in front of it.
There is no contract. You pay for the recorded minutes of tests that complete, and the pricing page has the rates.
What to check before you switch
- You need users you can reach. A few sessions a week are enough to start.
- Users take part when they choose to. You cannot order a number of sessions by a date.
- Screen recording works in supported desktop browsers.
- The test must be safe to run on a real account. Write the task so it stops before payment or anything that cannot be undone.
Start with one task
Copy the usability test script and task examples, or read how unmoderated usability testing works on your own site. The comparison with session replay is in Hotjar alternative.
Sign in and choose New study, or read the Quickstart first.